Zum Inhalt springen


Prose Parade
Grammar and writing basics


Between Who???

My nephew facebooked (from the verb to facebook; don’t you just love it when someone verbizes a noun?) me this morning and asked the age-old question: Is it between he and I or between him and me? The short answer is him and me.

He, him, I and me are pronouns and differ from what we’re used to in English because they have cases just as the Romance (French, Spanish, Portuguese, Italian, Latin) languages do. On top of that they’re irregular. Also, they’re left over from an older form of English. No wonder it’s confusing.

In the example the pronouns are objects of the preposition between and so are in the objective case, i.e., him and me. The nominative case (for nouns that are the subject of the sentence, for instance) is I and he. So, I never want to hear any of you say, “Me and him were going to the movies.” Or, you’ll hear me say like Mandy Patinkin in The Princess Bride, “Prepare to die.” And, I’ll roll the “r” just as long and as broadly as he did.

As a quick check when you’re writing the sentence or even speaking slowly enough to catch yourself, take out the other person. So, would you say, “between I”? No, you would not; you’d think it was funky, and it is. Would you say, “Me is going to the movies”? You would not. Then, don’t.

For more in-depth information see The Parts of Speech page.

« Hung/Hanged – Writing Tip »

Author:
admin
Date:
April 18, 2009 um 12:10 pm
Category:
Uncategorized
Tags:
 
Trackback:
Trackback URI

2 Comments »

  1. Steve

    Your nephew thanks you. He also wants you to know that he makes a daily visit to this website (Why isn’t it websight? I’ll need an answer by Monday, please.) now. It’s a good’n. Actually, he’s just hoping to catch you making a grammatical error of your own, as in, “MA is a great place to be FROM.”

    #1 Comment vom 18. April 2009 um 1:04 pm

  2. admin

    It’s not websight because it has nothing to do with seeing. It’s a site, a place. MA is a good place to be FROM is not a grammatical error. It’s all right to end a sentence with a preposition. There’s no rule anywhere that says so. It’s only in grade and high school teachers’ minds. That is, if they teach language arts, if they were taught language arts, and so on going into the dim, dark past.

    #2 Comment vom 22. April 2009 um 2:00 pm

Leave a comment